Author Archives: admin
← Older posts Newer posts →Sign up for the Afghanistan Study Group Newsletter.
February 15, 2011 Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a commentIf the Obama administration scales back the mission in Afghanistan, Republicans will portray it as “soft” and the Democratic Party will pay a big political price in the 2010 and 2012 elections.
February 14, 2011Our strategy in Afghanistan should be based on U.S. national interests, not partisan politics. Moreover, the war is increasingly unpopular with the American people. Voters will support a strategy that reduces costs, emphasizes counter-terrorism, and begins to bring U.S. troops … Continue reading
Posted in Myths | Leave a commentReducing the military effort in Afghanistan will cause allies to doubt our credibility and staying power. Some might even be tempted to cut deals with our adversaries.
February 14, 2011Public support for the allied mission in Afghanistan is lagging in almost all partner countries. The United States will strengthen its credibility among allies by coming forward with a realistic and pragmatic strategy for scaling back and eventually ending the … Continue reading
Posted in Featured Myth, Myths | 1 CommentThe U.S. scaling back its military mission in Afghanistan will threaten Pakistan’s stability and jeopardize control of its nuclear arsenal.
February 14, 2011A prolonged and unwinnable war is more likely to undermine stability in Pakistan than would the prompt scaling down of the U.S. military mission. There are many other steps that the United States could take to help secure Pakistan’s nuclear … Continue reading
Posted in Myths | Leave a commentWithdrawal from Afghanistan will be seen as a great victory for Al Qaeda and enhance its popularity and prestige. If we scale back our engagement in Afghanistan, they will simply follow us home.
February 14, 2011It is our military presence that is actively aiding Taliban recruitment and encouraging disparate extremist groups to back one another. The Afghan mujaheddin did not “follow the Soviets home” after they withdrew. The same will be true once the United … Continue reading
Posted in Myths | Leave a commentOur large-scale presence in Afghanistan is the only thing that will ensure women’s rights.
February 14, 2011The worst thing for women is for Afghanistan to remain paralyzed in a civil war in which there evolves no organically rooted support for their social advancement. Women’s rights are central to the progress of Afghanistan, and the international community … Continue reading
Posted in Myths | Leave a commentIf we leave Afghanistan, the Taliban will take over, Al Qaeda will re-establish itself there, and new and deadly attacks on America will be more likely.
February 14, 2011The Taliban are unpopular in much of Afghanistan and unlikely to take over the country. They might regain power in some areas, but Al Qaeda cannot recreate its former haven because—unlike before 9/11—the United States can easily detect and destroy … Continue reading
Posted in Myths | Leave a commentThere is no meaningful difference between the Taliban and Al Qaeda. They are part of a growing alliance of religious extremists that hate America and must be defeated at all costs.
February 14, 2011Al Qaeda and the Taliban are not the same – and in fact have many differences and disagreements. The Taliban is a coalition of political-military and tribal organizations that seeks power in Afghanistan. Al Qaeda is a global terrorist organization … Continue reading
Posted in Myths | Leave a commentThe Taliban is a group of religious fanatics who can never be appeased through negotiations.
February 14, 2011All societies contain some extremists who cannot be appeased, but they usually represent tiny minorities. Many factions within the Taliban have already shown a willingness to negotiate. They may be won over by proposals that will give them a share … Continue reading
Posted in Myths | 1 CommentThe “surge” in Iraq proves that counterinsurgency strategies can work; all we have to do is stay the course.
February 14, 2011The “surge” in Iraq was only a partial success, predicated as much on a program to pay wages to almost 100,000 Sunni that had been fighting against us as it was on an increase in troops. Conditions in Afghanistan are … Continue reading
Posted in Featured Myth, Myths | Leave a comment ← Older posts Newer posts →